My rejected letter to The Times – 4 June 2014

by Liam Byrne | 04.06.14 | in: Constituency news, Hodge Hill, Local Issues, Local News, National news, Schools, Tories, Uncategorized


Dear friends,


This morning I read with dismay the Times leader entitled ‘Trojan Horses’ about the situation in Birmingham Schools. You can read the patronising piece here: (£)


In response I wrote to the editor but they have refused to publish the letter in full.


See here below the letter I submitted to the letters page at the Times this morning, which they’ve refused to publish:


Dear Sir,


As a great admirer of your paper and its respect for facts, I was appalled at the grossly patronising tone of your leader today, headlined Trojan Horse.


Let’s be clear: the allegations about schools in Birmingham are serious. They demanded Ofsted inspection, which I was determined to ensure was conducted fast and forensically. But the conclusions from these inspections are not yet on the table. For reasons best known to Sir Michael Wilshaw and the Secretary of State, the reports remain secret, under wraps.


You therefore have not a shred of conclusive proof today that health and sex education was poor, that RE education was unbalanced, or that music and dancing was not permitted. Your conclusion therefore that the necessity of these requirements ‘need to be firmly explained to the parents and the communities [my constituents] sustaining the schools’ is so offensively patronising that it should not have graced your pages.


Our parents are as just ambitious as you for the best, well-rounded education possible for their children. Like me, they want their children to be leaders of our city and our country. What is extraordinary is that you had nothing to say about the potential failures of oversight of these academies – which let us remember Mr Gove is responsible for – and yet hint that somehow our parents are ‘lesser citizens’.


The questions at stake here cut to the heart of wider debates about the position of faith schools and the wider management of education reform. Don’t make parents the scapegoats for the sins and omissions of politicians – of whatever party they might be.




Rt Hon Liam Byrne MP




Related Posts

What are the causes of poverty and low income in Hodge Hill?

Our community is one of the poorest in Britain and over the summer I am updating my research into the causes of poverty and low income. I am looking for people to interview who have a household income of £13,000 a year or less. The telephone interview will be strictly confidential and will be undertaken […]

Read more

How the Tories’ DUP deal compares to funding for the West Midlands

The £1 billion deal Theresa May has struck with the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) is leaving the West Midlands massively short-changed.  I asked the House of Commons Library to dig into the figures and our analysis shows Northern Ireland will get £244 per head compared to £13 in the West Midlands – that’s more than […]

Read more

My response to the Grenfell disaster

Many constituents have written to me about the Grenfell fire. Most enquiries focused on fire-safety standards, the weakness of the Government’s response and the need to properly assist the victims of the fire in finding new housing and professional support in overcoming the tragedy that has befallen their community. I have prepared the following response: Tweet Share […]

Read more

Stay up to date with Liam's work

  • Latest Tweets

    • RT : It’s important the govt knows that scrapping RN and RM amphibious capabilities would be hugely detrimental to our n…

  • Copyright Liam Byrne MP 2017